Forums > General Industry > Photographers criticizing other photographers...

Photographer

JSouthworth

Posts: 2099

Kingston upon Hull, England, United Kingdom

Post hidden on Sep 07, 2025 01:39 pm
Reason: not helpful

Sep 07 25 07:10 am Link

Photographer

LightDreams

Posts: 4886

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

...and your accusations on MM that another, long established photographer and MM member, was ALSO a "dirty undercover cop" (that was, apparently, sent "to get you") was yet another product of your wild imagination.

Sep 07 25 08:04 am Link

Photographer

JSouthworth

Posts: 2099

Kingston upon Hull, England, United Kingdom

LightDreams wrote:
...and your accusations on MM that another, long established photographer and MM member, was ALSO a "dirty undercover cop" (that was, apparently, sent "to get you") was yet another product of your wild imagination.

YOUR imagination may be working overtime, if you're referring to the person I think you mean. "Long established photographer?" I don't think so. Dirty undercover cops are of course an occupational hazard in our business.

Sep 07 25 08:11 am Link

Photographer

LightDreams

Posts: 4886

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

JSouthworth wrote:
YOUR imagination may be working overtime

I don't know why JSouthworth even bothers to deny it  (NOTE:  He's now COMPLETELY CHANGED his original flat denial post above), when I found a long list of his slanderous claims to that effect, STILL ON MM.

He repeatedly claimed the MM photographer was everything from a "dirty undercover cop" to a "dirty undercover police officer" to "an undercover cop with a head problem", etc.

These are all DIRECT QUOTES from JSouthworth's CURRENTLY AVAILABLE MM posts.

In fact the MM photographer he accused (who had been on MM LONG before JSouthworth) finally had to make the following post (in response to JSouthworth's constant slanderous accusations).

<Name Removed> wrote:
For the record, and in case MM admin or anyone else believes Southy's statement(s) about me are true, I'm not and have never been a police officer - undercover, dirty or otherwise.

More complete sh*t from the troll.

Sep 07 25 08:37 am Link

Photographer

JSouthworth

Posts: 2099

Kingston upon Hull, England, United Kingdom

LightDreams wrote:
He repeatedly claimed the MM photographer was everything from a "dirty undercover cop" to a "dirty undercover police officer" to "an undercover cop with a head problem", etc.

I also messaged him (on another modelling site) to ask him whether he was working for West Midlands Police or for the Association of Chief Police Officers (ACPO), but he wasn't forthcoming on that question. There's no doubt in my mind that he was a police officer, or somebody with a serious pretence to being one. He had profiles under different names on various sites including PurplePort and Twitter/X.

Sep 07 25 09:09 am Link

Photographer

LightDreams

Posts: 4886

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

For those trying to keep track...

JSouthworth has gone from claiming:

- That he doesn't remember anything like any of this (his sudden "amnesia" stage)...

- To, okay, so he does remember the model he repeatedly accused (on MM for over 2 years) of being an undercover officer sent to entrap him, but has no memory of his constant accusations that another well-established photographer was ALSO a "dirty undercover cop" sent to MM to get him...

- To, flatly claiming that it didn't happen.  He made no such statements and that this was (apparently) all a product of my imagination.

- To, once his actual quotes were posted, he completely wiped out his flat denial lies, and has now gone back to his claims that the photographer in question (supposedly) REALLY WAS (yet another!) undercover cop that was "out to get him", so to speak.



Come to your own conclusions.

---

Another day in JSouthworth's world...

Sep 07 25 09:35 am Link

Admin

Mod 7 (Cust. Svc.)

Posts: 29576

El Segundo, California, US

Moderator Warning!
Please stop the back and forth bickering. And please stop gossiping about other people.

Sep 07 25 01:40 pm Link

Photographer

JQuest

Posts: 2562

Syracuse, New York, US

JSouthworth wrote:
I'm not stating that it isn't her real name. I suspect that it isn't her real name. And I haven't outed her as working for the police because she's discussed it on another modelling site forum.

It's probable that you're being disingenuous about not knowing the models real name since you never miss a chance to drop their name as being in your portfolio and your scrapbook, the gaslighting is ridiculously obvious. For the record when you take something that someone else has written about themselves from a password protected site (Linked In and another modeling site by your own admission) without their consent and then post it you are outing them. Especially when you post it in a publicly accessible forum such as MM's. You have no idea if they wanted that information divulged elsewhere, and we have no way of knowing what the context of that information was.

Thanks to the Moderators for deleting that information. We get that you feel you have been wrongly targeted by law enforcement, no one here can do anything about that, you should keep it to yourself as you're only making it worse by trying to defend what you did.

I will not be responding to anymore of your posts on this.

Sep 07 25 02:58 pm Link

Photographer

JSouthworth

Posts: 2099

Kingston upon Hull, England, United Kingdom

Post hidden on Sep 08, 2025 05:26 am
Reason: not helpful
Comments:
You just don't know when you quit.

Sep 08 25 12:38 am Link

Photographer

D L Photo

Posts: 79

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

everyone should subject themselves to a critique on here at least once.  some people only want to be compiimented, which is not going to help them improve

Jan 16 26 01:56 am Link

Photographer

Lucifers_Corner

Posts: 77

Decatur, Georgia, US

Generally speaking...

Why would McDonald's, Burger King, Checkers/Rallys, and White Castle waste their time asking Wendy's what "she" thinks about them, knowing damn well that she's in love with herself and will slander you to make herself look good? How does that work out for you?

The only opinion that counts is the customers'. If you want an honest critique, ask them. As long as they're satisfied, you should be happy.

Jan 22 26 01:08 pm Link

Model

Model Sarah

Posts: 41069

Columbus, Ohio, US

I remember a million years ago there were two INCREDIBLY talented photographers in the forums here who were giving VERY sound advice (this was before the critique part was created) to photographers. I believe this was in the photography part of the forums. These amateur "photographers" (we used to call them GWCs) were getting so angry and upset that (remember these were insanely talented guys) someone was telling them a better way to shoot something. (Think wrinkled bed sheets as a backdrop "photographers".) These guys just thought buying expensive equipment would make them better.

It was hilarious and kind of sad to watch. I remember both of them stopped posting and even one left because of how frustrating it was for him. They weren't being assholes or anything like that. I remember them being helpful and technical, sometimes funny.

Jan 27 26 08:59 am Link

Photographer

Chris Macan

Posts: 13197

HAVERTOWN, Pennsylvania, US

Model Sarah wrote:
These amateur "photographers" (we used to call them GWCs) were getting so angry and upset that (remember these were insanely talented guys) someone was telling them a better way to shoot something. (Think wrinkled bed sheets as a backdrop "photographers".) These guys just thought buying expensive equipment would make them better.

wronkled" the sheets were "wronkled'........

Jan 27 26 01:56 pm Link

Photographer

Lucifers_Corner

Posts: 77

Decatur, Georgia, US

Chris Macan wrote:

wronkled" the sheets were "wronkled'........

Ah, memories.

Jan 27 26 03:28 pm Link

Model

Model Sarah

Posts: 41069

Columbus, Ohio, US

Lucifers_Corner wrote:

Ah, memories.

Holy shit, I just realized who you are. Wow.

Jan 28 26 01:58 pm Link

Photographer

Arizona Shoots

Posts: 28888

Phoenix, Arizona, US

Model Sarah wrote:
I remember a million years ago there were two INCREDIBLY talented photographers in the forums here who were giving VERY sound advice (this was before the critique part was created) to photographers. I believe this was in the photography part of the forums. These amateur "photographers" (we used to call them GWCs) were getting so angry and upset that (remember these were insanely talented guys) someone was telling them a better way to shoot something. (Think wrinkled bed sheets as a backdrop "photographers".) These guys just thought buying expensive equipment would make them better.

It was hilarious and kind of sad to watch. I remember both of them stopped posting and even one left because of how frustrating it was for him. They weren't being assholes or anything like that. I remember them being helpful and technical, sometimes funny.

Sometimes I get the sense that there are a lot of photographers (especially on MM) only want to impress other photographers. I've been guilty of that too. But then I had an epiphany. The only thing that really matters to me anymore is that the model is impressed. Everyting else is just noise.

Jan 28 26 03:44 pm Link

Model

Model Sarah

Posts: 41069

Columbus, Ohio, US

Arizona Shoots wrote:

Sometimes I get the sense that there are a lot of photographers (especially on MM) only want to impress other photographers. I've been guilty of that too. But then I had an epiphany. The only thing that really matters to me anymore is that the model is impressed. Everyting else is just noise.

Totally agreed.

But I just never understood the vitriol or combativeness from said photographers. It would be different if the two talented photographers were saying; YOU SUCK DUMMY! But they were not. They were genuinely trying to help.  I suppose it is just jealousy and insecure or even projection but jesus. To drive insane talent off of a forum for trying to help is crazy to me. I just don't understand it.

Jan 28 26 03:57 pm Link

Photographer

Arizona Shoots

Posts: 28888

Phoenix, Arizona, US

Model Sarah wrote:
Totally agreed.

But I just never understood the vitriol or combativeness from said photographers. It would be different if the two talented photographers were saying; YOU SUCK DUMMY! But they were not. They were genuinely trying to help.  I suppose it is just jealousy and insecure or even projection but jesus. To drive insane talent off of a forum for trying to help is crazy to me. I just don't understand it.

Swinging their dicks.

Jan 28 26 06:45 pm Link

Photographer

EdBPhotography

Posts: 7746

Torrance, California, US

Chris Macan wrote:

wronkled" the sheets were "wronkled'........

And "drappy."

Jan 29 26 08:00 pm Link

Photographer

Lucifers_Corner

Posts: 77

Decatur, Georgia, US

EdBPhotography wrote:

And "drappy."

Wait...

I was "graped" of mind and body.

Jan 29 26 10:11 pm Link

Photographer

Lucifers_Corner

Posts: 77

Decatur, Georgia, US

Model Sarah wrote:

Holy shit, I just realized who you are. Wow.

Pleased to meet you
Hope you guess my name
But what's puzzlin' you
Is the nature of my game.

Jan 29 26 10:23 pm Link

Model

Model Sarah

Posts: 41069

Columbus, Ohio, US

Lucifers_Corner wrote:

Pleased to meet you
Hope you guess my name
But what's puzzlin' you
Is the nature of my game.

Just wishing you hadn't gone off into the deep end...

P.S. Can't wait to leave this world behind next week! hienvy

Jan 30 26 07:36 am Link

Photographer

Lucifers_Corner

Posts: 77

Decatur, Georgia, US

Model Sarah wrote:

Just wishing you hadn't gone off into the deep end...

P.S. Can't wait to leave this world behind next week! hienvy

What an interesting statement. The deep end of what, exactly?

Jan 30 26 09:10 am Link

Photographer

DTP - Photography

Posts: 103

Chesapeake, Virginia, US

Lucifers_Corner wrote:

What an interesting statement. The deep end of what, exactly?

Apparently, this page. She has left before and come I believe.

Jan 31 26 06:31 pm Link

Photographer

Lucifers_Corner

Posts: 77

Decatur, Georgia, US

DTP - Photography wrote:

Apparently, this page. She has left before and come I believe.

Hey, phrasing.

Feb 03 26 03:20 am Link

Photographer

Audrey Rinehart

Posts: 60

New York, New York, US

Chris Macan wrote:

wronkled" the sheets were "wronkled'........

Remember when people on the MM forums referred to adult materials "pr0nz" ?

Pr0nz was lingo of the Wronkled Sheet era

Feb 25 26 04:45 pm Link

Photographer

Chris Macan

Posts: 13197

HAVERTOWN, Pennsylvania, US

Audrey Rinehart wrote:

Remember when people on the MM forums referred to adult materials "pr0nz" ?

Pr0nz was lingo of the Wronkled Sheet era

I had forgotten the "pr0nz"!
Thank you, I needed more of that in my life....

This was the stupid shit that made the forums fun.

Feb 25 26 05:40 pm Link

Photographer

Audrey Rinehart

Posts: 60

New York, New York, US

Chris Macan wrote:

I had forgotten the "pr0nz"!
Thank you, I needed more of that in my life....

This was the stupid shit that made the forums fun.

lol

Feb 25 26 06:43 pm Link

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 30211

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Model Sarah wrote:
I remember a million years ago there were two INCREDIBLY talented photographers in the forums here who were giving VERY sound advice (this was before the critique part was created) to photographers. I believe this was in the photography part of the forums. These amateur "photographers" (we used to call them GWCs) were getting so angry and upset that (remember these were insanely talented guys) someone was telling them a better way to shoot something. (Think wrinkled bed sheets as a backdrop "photographers".) These guys just thought buying expensive equipment would make them better.

It was hilarious and kind of sad to watch. I remember both of them stopped posting and even one left because of how frustrating it was for him. They weren't being assholes or anything like that. I remember them being helpful and technical, sometimes funny.

I believe that I started out as one of those wonkled sheet GWCs to some degree

And Yes there were some Very Talented Photographers like Neil Snape who provided great feedback that helped me grow

But there were also some Very Talented Photographers who were quite Nasty as well

I didn’t really complain much about that though because I was quite nasty myself in some ways

Feb 25 26 09:40 pm Link

Photographer

Camera Buff

Posts: 1111

Maryborough, Queensland, Australia

Arizona Shoots wrote:
I found this to be pretty good insight on the subject..
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1q-GZkOwGco

Photographers criticizing other photographers..

It is important to filter out unhelpful noise, focus on your own creative goals, and recognize that criticism is often subjective.

Feb 25 26 10:07 pm Link

Model

Model Sarah

Posts: 41069

Columbus, Ohio, US

Garry k wrote:

I believe that I started out as one of those wonkled sheet GWCs to some degree

And Yes there were some Very Talented Photographers like Neil Snape who provided great feedback that helped me grow

But there were also some Very Talented Photographers who were quite Nasty as well

I didn’t really complain much about that though because I was quite nasty myself in some ways

Mmm..... hear me out... If I remember correctly, you never really understood internet humor. The one photographer I am talking about was almost a stand up comedian. But sometimes that doesn't go well online ESPECIALLY 20 YEARS AGO.

hienvy

Feb 26 26 10:12 am Link

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 30211

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Model Sarah wrote:
Mmm..... hear me out... If I remember correctly, you never really understood internet humor. The one photographer I am talking about was almost a stand up comedian. But sometimes that doesn't go well online ESPECIALLY 20 YEARS AGO.

hienvy

Honestly I found my own humour in things

and there were a lot of people and a lot of things to laugh at

Feb 26 26 06:09 pm Link